Two adult party games, two different jobs
Drink IF... and BAD CHOICES both promise fast laughs with a group of friends, but they are not interchangeable. Drink IF... is an adult drinking game built around shared experiences: one player reads a card, and anyone the statement applies to takes a sip. BAD CHOICES is a conversation and icebreaker card game that mixes "Never Have I Ever" confessions with UNO-style strategy, so the fun comes from funny truths and unexpected stories rather than from drinking.
That difference matters more than the box art suggests. If your group is pregaming before a night out, a drinking game keeps the energy high and the rules invisible. If you want a game that works at a house party where some people aren't drinking, or you want something that rewards a little strategy, the conversation card game is the safer pick. The rest of this comparison breaks down the practical differences so you can choose for the night you're actually planning.
How each game actually plays
- Drink IF...: One player reads a card out loud. If you've done it or it applies to you, you drink — including the reader. The supplied rules say you can play casually or turn up the competition by deciding your own house rules and winning conditions. There is no built-in scoring system in the supplied information, so the game leans on the group's energy rather than a points race.
- BAD CHOICES: The game combines the fun of "Never Have I Ever" with the strategy of UNO. That means players aren't just confessing — they're making choices that affect the round. The supplied description emphasizes funny truths, unexpected stories, and a game that plays differently every time depending on the group.
Player count, age limits, and play time
Both games are designed for 3 or more players and list a 20–45 minute play time, so group size and session length won't separate them. The age floor will. Drink IF... is listed for ages 21+, which fits its drinking-game format. BAD CHOICES is listed for ages 15+, so it can include older teens and adults who aren't drinking.
If your guest list includes anyone under 21, or a mix of drinkers and non-drinkers, BAD CHOICES removes the awkward workaround of substituting water for every sip. If your group is all adults and the point of the night is drinking, Drink IF... is the more direct fit.
What you get in each box
- Drink IF… Adult Drinking Game for Parties | Funny Icebreaker & Conversation Starter Card Game for Friends and Groups | Great for Bachelor Party, Game Night and Pregames| Fun Gift for Adults: 600 Question Cards, Ages 21+, 20–45 minutes gameplay, 3+ players. The 600-card count gives the drinking game a large pool of statements, which matters for repeat pregames with the same friend group.

Drink IF… Adult Drinking Game for Parties | Funny Icebreaker & Conversation Starter Card Game for Friends and Groups | Great for Bachelor Party, Game Night and Pregames| Fun Gift for Adults - BAD CHOICES Party Game + After Dark Set – Hilarious Adult Card Game for Friends & Game Night | Funny Conversation & Icebreaker Board Game for Parties, Pregames, Social Gatherings & Fun Gift Ideas: 400 outrageous cards; Ages 15+, 20–45 minutes gameplay, 3+ players. The lower age floor and 400-card count make BAD CHOICES the more flexible option for mixed-age or non-drinking groups.

BAD CHOICES Party Game + After Dark Set – Hilarious Adult Card Game for Friends & Game Night | Funny Conversation & Icebreaker Board Game for Parties, Pregames, Social Gatherings & Fun Gift Ideas
Where each game fits best
Drink IF... is built for pregames, house parties, birthdays, bachelor and bachelorette parties, and weekend hangouts — the supplied description names those occasions directly. It also works as an adult gift for holidays, white elephant exchanges, Secret Santa, and stocking stuffers. The game plays differently every time depending on the group, which keeps it fresh across repeated parties.
BAD CHOICES is positioned for game night, pregames, house parties, college hangouts, birthdays, and time with friends, and it's also pitched as an adult gift for holidays, white elephant exchanges, Secret Santa, and birthdays. The strategic layer gives it a little more staying power at a sit-down game night, while the confession format keeps it social enough for a pregame.
The tradeoffs you should know before buying
The clearest tradeoff is the drinking requirement. Drink IF... assumes players will take sips, so it doesn't work as smoothly for a sober crowd or a mixed-age group. The supplied information doesn't describe a non-alcoholic alternative, so plan around that if your guest list includes non-drinkers.
BAD CHOICES has the opposite limitation: because it's a conversation and strategy card game rather than a drinking game, it won't deliver the same fast, sip-driven energy that a pregame group might expect. If your group wants a game that keeps drinks moving, the UNO-style structure may feel like a detour.
One more practical note: the supplied records don't include detailed setup instructions or a full rules breakdown for either game. Both are described as easy to learn and quick to play, but if you need exact rules before buying, check the product pages rather than assuming the mechanics from the box copy.
Which one should you buy?
Choose Drink IF... if your group is all 21 or older, the night revolves around drinking, and you want a game with essentially no learning curve. The 600-card count and the "take a sip if it applies to you" format make it a natural pregame and party choice.
Choose BAD CHOICES if you want an adult card game that works for game night, includes older teens or non-drinkers, and adds a bit of strategy to the confession format. The 400-card set and the 15+ age floor give it more flexibility across different gatherings.
If you're buying for a gift exchange and don't know the recipient's group well, BAD CHOICES is the lower-risk pick because it doesn't depend on everyone drinking. If you know the recipient hosts pregames, Drink IF... is the more targeted gift.



